| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Good idea |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 1#Good idea
|
| Advertise |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 1#Advertise
|
| external meeting |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 1#external meeting
|
| Policy? |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Policy?
|
| Past actions |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Past actions
|
| Extent of "pedophilia is instantly blockable" |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Extent of "pedophilia is instantly blockable"
|
| What about the Fox News story? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#What about the Fox News story?
|
| Arbcom |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Arbcom
|
| Wikimedia Foundation |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Wikimedia Foundation
|
| Sketch out a policy |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Sketch out a policy
|
| Discriminatory policy |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Discriminatory policy
|
| Comment |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Comment
|
| Facts of past action essay |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Facts of past action essay
|
| Making all of Europe paedophiles |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Making all of Europe paedophiles
|
| Let's Get To It |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Let's Get To It
|
| Comment from a sitting arbitrator |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Comment from a sitting arbitrator
|
| Comparison with other websites |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Comparison with other websites
|
| What is meant by "neutral block summary"? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#What is meant by "neutral block summary"?
|
| This page should be classed as policy |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#This page should be classed as policy
|
| Disabling email |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Disabling email
|
| Recent copy edits |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Recent copy edits
|
| Basically, I do not understand what this is really about |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Basically, I do not understand what this is really about
|
| An opinion |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#An opinion
|
| On the power of ArbCom |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#On the power of ArbCom
|
| Shortcut |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#Shortcut
|
| "I believe my position is shared by a vast majority" |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 2#"I believe my position is shared by a vast majority"
|
| What is about Neutral point of view? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#What is about Neutral point of view?
|
| Policy |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Policy
|
| Please explain this policy |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Please explain this policy
|
| WP:CENT |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#WP:CENT
|
| What about pot smokers? |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#What about pot smokers?
|
| Time for a full RfC involving the entire community? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Time for a full RfC involving the entire community?
|
| Huh?? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Huh??
|
| RfC |
44 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#RfC
|
| Copy edit |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Copy edit
|
| page is a bit big |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#page is a bit big
|
| What recourse is there? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#What recourse is there?
|
| The theory should be based on WP:HARASSMENT, recognizing threats of child rape as threats of violence |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#The theory should be based on WP:HARASSMENT, recognizing threats of child rape as threats of violence
|
| Why this policy exists |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Why this policy exists
|
| That may have been the most ham-handed thing I've ever seen... |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#That may have been the most ham-handed thing I've ever seen...
|
| Unless we block all under 18s from editing |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Unless we block all under 18s from editing
|
| Informing authorities |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Informing authorities
|
| Remove tag |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Remove tag
|
| Should deal with all criminal activity |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Should deal with all criminal activity
|
| Still not getting it |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Still not getting it
|
| Why there should be no policy-tag on this policy |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Why there should be no policy-tag on this policy
|
| Cooperation with law enforcement agencies |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Cooperation with law enforcement agencies
|
| conflation |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#conflation
|
| An experiment |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#An experiment
|
| Could someone point to where WP:PROPOSAL was followed? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Could someone point to where WP:PROPOSAL was followed?
|
| time for ArbCom? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#time for ArbCom?
|
| self-identifying on Wikipedia is advocacy |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#self-identifying on Wikipedia is advocacy
|
| Self identifying on Wikipedia is advocacy |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Self identifying on Wikipedia is advocacy
|
| Name of this page |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Name of this page
|
| Proposal--do this the "right" way. |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Proposal--do this the "right" way.
|
| Concrete proposal |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Concrete proposal
|
| Childish bickering over tags |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Childish bickering over tags
|
| Deletion |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Deletion
|
| Unnecessary and unsound |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Unnecessary and unsound
|
| It appears some Wiki editors refuse to accept Pedophilia restrictions |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#It appears some Wiki editors refuse to accept Pedophilia restrictions
|
| Thinking outside the box |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Thinking outside the box
|
| Is there community consensus to support as policy |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Is there community consensus to support as policy
|
| Common ground |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Common ground
|
| Proposed rewrite |
45 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Proposed rewrite
|
| Move to a subpage of wp:arbitration? |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Move to a subpage of wp:arbitration?
|
| NPOV does not require the acceptance of advocacy |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#NPOV does not require the acceptance of advocacy
|
| Let's be practical. |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Let's be practical.
|
| Simple solution |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Simple solution
|
| Attempts to Normalize Pedophilia |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Attempts to Normalize Pedophilia
|
| While you've all been arguing, I've been doing something useful |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#While you've all been arguing, I've been doing something useful
|
| Editing a fully-protected page |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Editing a fully-protected page
|
| Handling of mistakes or pedophile jokes |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Handling of mistakes or pedophile jokes
|
| Relationships? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#Relationships?
|
| Redirect this page now |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 3#Redirect this page now
|
| Content control |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#Content control
|
| Thoughts |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#Thoughts
|
| E-mail address in the article |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#E-mail address in the article
|
| AN/I |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#AN/I
|
| Consistency |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#Consistency
|
| No longer policy? |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#No longer policy?
|
| Archive |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#Archive
|
| This is policy |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#This is policy
|
| Questioning another editor about whether they are a pedophile, or pedophilia advocate |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#Questioning another editor about whether they are a pedophile, or pedophilia advocate
|
| inappropriate? |
39 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#inappropriate?
|
| Thought police |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 4#Thought police
|
| Counterproductive to ban anyone who "self-identifies as a pedophile" |
49 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#Counterproductive to ban anyone who "self-identifies as a pedophile"
|
| "Self-identifying" as a pedophile |
52 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#"Self-identifying" as a pedophile
|
| Reporting |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#Reporting
|
| alternately: block e-mail for minors |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#alternately: block e-mail for minors
|
| Self-identifying" as a pedophile - revisited |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#Self-identifying" as a pedophile - revisited
|
| Random Break |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#Random Break
|
| Self-identifying as racists |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#Self-identifying as racists
|
| past, or only present |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#past, or only present
|
| Concerns about meta and commons |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 5#Concerns about meta and commons
|
| New section |
36 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#New section
|
| RevDelete vs Oversight for accusations of paedophilia. |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#RevDelete vs Oversight for accusations of paedophilia.
|
| I don't think Jimbo mandated a pedophile protection policy - blocks against accusers are NOT a good idea and I think we deserve a vote about it |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#I don't think Jimbo mandated a pedophile protection policy - blocks against accusers are NOT a good idea and I think we deserve a vote about it
|
| Safety measures |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#Safety measures
|
| Content and enforcement? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#Content and enforcement?
|
| (Somewhat) related discussion: proposed ArbCom policy change |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#(Somewhat) related discussion: proposed ArbCom policy change
|
| This policy and the Code of Conduct Policy |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#This policy and the Code of Conduct Policy
|
| Suggestion regarding users blocked for violating this policy |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#Suggestion regarding users blocked for violating this policy
|
| Page semiprotected for 3 days |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#Page semiprotected for 3 days
|
| Child Protection vs. NPOV |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#Child Protection vs. NPOV
|
| CNN goes on the warpath against Amazon.com |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#CNN goes on the warpath against Amazon.com
|
| The vagueness... |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#The vagueness...
|
| Question about "who identify themselves as paedophiles" |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#Question about "who identify themselves as paedophiles"
|
| The death of wikipedia |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#The death of wikipedia
|
| Horribly misguided and a mark of shame |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Horribly misguided and a mark of shame
|
| Template suggestion - User current age |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Template suggestion - User current age
|
| I strongly disagree with (parts of) this policy. |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#I strongly disagree with (parts of) this policy.
|
| This policy is SICK! |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#This policy is SICK!
|
| Can we remove some of the prohibition against public accusation? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Can we remove some of the prohibition against public accusation?
|
| Is bestiality OK? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Is bestiality OK?
|
| Where are the actual child protection guidelines? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Where are the actual child protection guidelines?
|
| Odd redirect |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Odd redirect
|
| The policy template |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#The policy template
|
| Arbcom address |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Arbcom address
|
| Recent minor addition |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Recent minor addition
|
| Sex Offenders |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Sex Offenders
|
| A comment at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rape and Pregnancy |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#A comment at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rape and Pregnancy
|
| Repeal the pedophile protection provisions, part 2 |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Repeal the pedophile protection provisions, part 2
|
| RfC |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 6#RfC
|
| About awareness |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#About awareness
|
| Seriously concerns |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Seriously concerns
|
| Clarification needed on some issues |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Clarification needed on some issues
|
| Objections |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Objections
|
| Images |
154 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Images
|
| Is This Being Discussed in Another Project Also? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Is This Being Discussed in Another Project Also?
|
| Privacy Question: Pictures of Children in General |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Privacy Question: Pictures of Children in General
|
| Old Weird Redirect |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 7#Old Weird Redirect
|
| A Terminological Point |
31 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#A Terminological Point
|
| http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/User talk:Sue Gardner#Child protection |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/User talk:Sue Gardner#Child protection
|
| A minor technical point, which is based upon several discussions on Featured Articles objections regarding images |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#A minor technical point, which is based upon several discussions on Featured Articles objections regarding images
|
| Overkill definition of "personal information" |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Overkill definition of "personal information"
|
| Justification? |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Justification?
|
| Hatnote |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Hatnote
|
| 2013 International child pornography investigation |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#2013 International child pornography investigation
|
| "Inappropriate relationships" and "vague" tag |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#"Inappropriate relationships" and "vague" tag
|
| Wikimedia Foundation Terms of Use and advice about this issue |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#Wikimedia Foundation Terms of Use and advice about this issue
|
| better explination of former statement. |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 8#better explination of former statement.
|
| Guidance for younger editors |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 9#Guidance for younger editors
|
| Updating handling of reports |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 9#Updating handling of reports
|
| Counseling younger editors |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 9#Counseling younger editors
|
| Disclosing as a minor, but no identifying information |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 9#Disclosing as a minor, but no identifying information
|
| Policy questions |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 9#Policy questions
|
| What if |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 9#What if
|
| Confused about policy |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection/Archive 9#Confused about policy
|
| Timeframe for violations |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection#Timeframe for violations
|
| No legal threats |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Child protection#No legal threats
|
